FAQ
Common questions
Should I start with stock removal or bladesmithing?
Stock removal, without question. Forging requires learning hammer technique, fire management, and how to move hot steel simultaneously. Stock removal lets you focus on just two skills: grinding and heat treatment. After 5-10 stock removal knives, you'll know whether you want to add forging to your practice.
How much does it cost to start knifemaking?
For stock removal, expect $280-480 total: a 1×30 belt sander ($70), a single-burner propane forge ($180), safety gear ($50), steel bar stock ($20-30), and handle materials ($20-30). Files, pins, and epoxy bring it to about $400 when you add it all up.
Can I heat treat with just a propane torch?
For small blades (under 4 inches), a MAPP or propane torch can work for 1084. It's harder to heat evenly and easier to overheat the edge; a torch heats a spot, a forge heats the whole blade. Use a forge if you can; use a torch only if you can't set up a forge yet.
What's the best beginner knife design?
A simple drop-point hunter or utility knife with a full tang: 3-4 inch blade, no filework or complex geometry. The less complicated your first design, the more you'll learn about the fundamentals. Save the bowie and the recurve for knife 5 or 6.
How long does it take to make a first knife?
Expect 15-25 hours for your first knife, spread over several sessions. By knife 5, that same design takes 6-8 hours. The time drops dramatically as your grinding efficiency improves.
Do I need to anneal the steel before grinding?
If you buy 1084 bar stock as-annealed from a knifemaking supplier (most ship this way), you don't need to re-anneal before grinding. If you're using steel from a recycled source like old sawblades or files, normalize it 2-3 times to relieve stress before you profile.